On God, Faith, and Learning to Trust What I Cannot Control

What happens when someone questions your faith, and the conversation forces you to examine what you actually believe?
A friend of mine recently reached out after listening to several episodes of The Branding Laboratory, where I've had conversations about consciousness, identity, spirituality, human behavior, and the nature of existence.
Something about those conversations left her questioning my relationship with God. More specifically, she perceived what she understood to be a lack of belief or faith in a deity.
And just to be clear, she wasn't necessarily approaching this from a Christian perspective or challenging my adherence to any particular religion, her question was more fundamental than that… did I believe in God at all?
I appreciated the conversation because it made me realize how easily our understanding of someone else's beliefs can become filtered through our own interpretation of what those beliefs are supposed to look like.
It also gave me an opportunity to articulate something I've spent considerable time exploring, both intellectually and through the circumstances of my own life.
I'm sharing this because the question of faith reaches into something far more personal than religion for me. It touches my relationship with achievement, control, uncertainty, and the trust I place in myself when life refuses to unfold according to my expectations.
And perhaps there's something here for you, too, whether you believe in God, understand faith differently, or have simply found yourself questioning the assumptions through which you've made sense of your life.
What I Actually Believe About God
I think there's a fundamental misunderstanding about my relationship with God, and perhaps that's because my interpretation of God is considerably different from the traditional religious framework through which most people understand faith.
I absolutely believe in the possibility, and even the likelihood, of a creative intelligence responsible for existence. Where my thinking diverges is in the assumption that this intelligence necessarily operates as a personal, interventionist authority governing our individual decisions, rewarding our faith, or determining our success and failure.
My understanding of God is closer to a form of philosophical deism, informed by Gnostic cosmology, Taoist philosophy, and certain Buddhist principles concerning consciousness, attachment, and the nature of suffering.
I see creation as something vastly more complex, multidimensional, and potentially hierarchical than our current understanding allows us to comprehend.
The Possibility of a Much Larger Reality
Consider the possibility that what we call the universe is itself one expression of a much larger creative intelligence, and that within this greater reality exist additional layers of creation, consciousness, and organization.
Much like a sophisticated simulation containing smaller simulations, I entertain the possibility that existence operates through nested systems, each with its own architecture, governing principles, and degrees of autonomy.
Within that framework, what humanity understands as Earth, civilization, and even the observable cosmos may represent only a fraction of a much larger reality.
I remain open to the possibility that there are dimensions of existence, forms of intelligence, and aspects of our own world that we have yet to discover or properly understand. Some of my suspicions extend to the possibility that our knowledge of this planet's geography, history, and inhabitants is incomplete in ways we cannot presently appreciate.
I recognize, however, that there is an important distinction between what can be empirically demonstrated and what I consider metaphysically possible.
My willingness to explore these ideas is an expression of intellectual curiosity rather than a claim that I possess definitive knowledge of the universe's hidden architecture.
What If Faith Isn't About Waiting for God to Provide?
This is where my understanding of God becomes particularly relevant to the question of faith.
I don't necessarily believe that God is an external authority waiting for me to demonstrate sufficient devotion before granting me financial stability, professional success, or personal fulfillment.
I lean toward the belief that whatever intelligence gave rise to existence also gave us the capacity to participate in creation through consciousness, imagination, discernment, choice, and action.
In other words, perhaps faith was never intended to be exclusively about believing that God will provide. Perhaps it also involves developing sufficient trust in ourselves to participate responsibly in the creative process.
And this is where I recognize my own struggle.
When the Need for Control Becomes Its Own Prison
For much of my life, I have operated under the assumption that greater effort, increased discipline, and more aggressive pursuit of an outcome should produce proportionately greater success.
That conditioning has served me in certain respects, but it has also created a psychological relationship with achievement in which my sense of security becomes dependent upon my ability to control results.
When those results fail to materialize, my instinct is to work harder, analyze more, and attempt to exert even greater control over circumstances that may never have been entirely within my control.
I am beginning to understand that this pattern is as much an issue of identity and attachment as it is one of strategy or ambition.
What Have I Actually Been Putting My Faith In?
While exploring these questions, I listened to a recording about scientists, philosophers, and other public thinkers reconsidering their beliefs about God.
It's presented largely through a Christian lens, and although I don't necessarily agree with all the conclusions, several of the conversations caught my attention for reasons that had little to do with proving or disproving God's existence.
At one point, Steven Bartlett acknowledges that he suspects some kind of God exists, although he doesn't know what that God might be.
I appreciate the intellectual humility in that position. There is something remarkably liberating about being willing to entertain an idea without feeling compelled to define it, defend it, or claim certainty about something we may not yet be capable of fully understanding.
But the part that resonated most deeply with me involved neuroscientist Andrew Huberman, who described experimenting with prayer during a particularly difficult period in his life.
What interested me wasn't whether prayer could be scientifically demonstrated to produce divine intervention. It was his description of the peace he experienced when he began releasing his need to control circumstances that were never entirely within his control.
He also described praying before interviews, asking for help moving his ego out of the room.
I found that particularly interesting because it brought me back to something I've been struggling to reconcile in my own life.
And then Jordan Peterson introduced another provocative idea: that we all organize our lives around something we consider fundamentally important, whether we consciously recognize it or not.
He describes this through the language of worship. I'm not necessarily convinced that our highest priorities and God are interchangeable concepts, but the question itself gave me something to think about.
If I examine what consumes my attention, what I sacrifice for, what I fear losing, and what I allow to determine whether I'm succeeding or failing, how much of my life has been organized around achievement and control?
And if those things have become so deeply intertwined with my sense of identity, perhaps I've been placing far more faith in my ability to manufacture favorable outcomes than I've been willing to acknowledge.
The irony is difficult to ignore.
I've spent considerable time questioning whether God operates as a transactional authority, rewarding the faithful with favorable circumstances, while simultaneously operating as though enough hard work, discipline, and determination should entitle me to certain outcomes.
Perhaps I've rejected the idea of a transactional relationship with God while maintaining a similarly transactional relationship with life itself.
And that possibility has given me considerably more to think about than whether someone else's definition of God aligns with my own.
WHY DOES THIS MATTER TO ME?
You may have a completely different understanding of God, faith, or spirituality than I do, and still recognize something familiar in this experience.
Consider how much of your confidence comes from your ability to produce results, solve problems, provide for others, or maintain some sense of control over your circumstances.
What happens to that confidence when the methods that have always worked for you suddenly stop producing the outcomes you expect?
And perhaps more importantly, have you learned to trust yourself only when life gives you evidence that you're succeeding?
These are questions worth exploring because the beliefs we develop about achievement, security, and control can quietly influence our relationships, our decisions, our businesses, and ultimately how we experience our lives.
The Difference Between Intention and Attachment
The Buddhist concept of nonattachment, the Taoist principle of wu wei, and the Stoic distinction between what is and is not within our control all point toward a similar insight: there is a meaningful difference between acting with intention and becoming psychologically imprisoned by the outcome of that action.
I understand that distinction intellectually, but embodying it is another matter entirely.
I am still learning how to reconcile ambition with acceptance, personal responsibility with surrender, and the desire to create with the recognition that creation cannot always be forced into existence through sheer effort.
And perhaps that is where my actual crisis of faith resides.
When the Methods That Built Your Confidence Stop Working
I have spent much of my life developing confidence through evidence, performance, and accomplishment.
I trust what I can demonstrate, understand, or produce. Consequently, when I encounter circumstances in which my previous methods no longer yield predictable results, I struggle to maintain the same confidence in myself and the process.
I am attempting to move from a model of existence built primarily around control toward one grounded in conscious participation.
I want to understand how to pursue meaningful outcomes without allowing their realization, or temporary absence, to determine my internal state.
Learning to Architect Myself
This is what I mean when I talk about learning to architect myself.
I am examining the beliefs, conditioned responses, fears, expectations, and identities through which I experience reality, recognizing that some of the very mechanisms that once helped me succeed may now be limiting my capacity to evolve.
I am somewhere between understanding these principles intellectually and learning to live them experientially.
So when someone suggests that my difficulties arise from a lack of faith in God, I think that explanation overlooks the complexity of what I'm actually exploring.
Perhaps My Crisis of Faith Is Something Else Entirely
I believe there may be an extraordinary intelligence behind existence. I believe human consciousness and agency are meaningful aspects of that existence. And I believe our relationship with reality is considerably more complex than the transactional notion that sufficient religious faith produces favorable material outcomes.
What I am questioning is how to live in alignment with that understanding, particularly when circumstances challenge my confidence, my expectations, and my deeply conditioned need for control.
Perhaps the most meaningful expression of faith for me is learning to trust that I can participate fully in life, exercise the agency available to me, and remain internally grounded even when the outcome remains uncertain.
My struggle is not necessarily a lack of faith in God. It is learning how to trust myself, the process of becoming, and the larger reality of which I am only one very small part.
And I suspect that understanding this distinction is far more important to my spiritual development than convincing myself to adopt someone else's definition of God.
Comments