top of page

The Kobayashi Maru Problem

Deevo Tindall
Nov 13
8 min read
The Kobayashi Maru Problem cars lined up.

The rules you inherited, the choices you accepted, and what happens when you finally question the game.


A few days ago, I was helping my daughter move into college, an experience apparently designed to test the depth of parental love through humidity, miniature elevators, overpacked SUVs, and parking instructions conceived by people who seem to have only encountered automobiles in theory.


The designated unloading areas were full.


Ten feet away sat a perfectly respectable collection of empty parking spaces, quietly minding their own business, except some official decree had apparently determined that nobody involved in moving a small apartment’s worth of belongings into a dormitory was allowed to use them.


So I parked there.


Another parent watched me for a second, looked around as if waiting for lightning to strike, and parked right beside me. Then somebody else did the same thing. Within a few minutes I had accidentally founded a small autonomous parking republic, and I found myself wondering whether I had exposed an obvious flaw in the system or simply concluded, once again, that surely the rules could not have been written with someone as resourceful as me in mind.


Knowing myself, there was probably a healthy amount of both involved.


I have always had a complicated relationship with rules. There is a wonderfully flattering version of that story where I am the clever contrarian wandering through life questioning convention while everyone else dutifully follows the signs, and I would love to tell you that version because it makes me sound insufferably interesting.


It would also leave out some fairly important evidence.


Somewhere underneath my instinct to question systems lives a much older reflex that gets mildly irritated whenever someone tells me how something is supposed to be done without explaining why. I grew up in a house where rules tended to arrive carrying the full weight of authority, and questioning the reasoning behind them rarely produced the spirited intellectual debate I may have been hoping for.


So I became fascinated with the architecture underneath instructions.


Whenever somebody tells me there is a correct way to do something, some part of my brain immediately wants to know what we are actually trying to accomplish, why this particular method became sacred, and who decided the available choices before the rest of us arrived.


I realize this makes me sound exhausting… and… there is evidence to support that conclusion.


The Thread


We spend extraordinary amounts of energy solving problems inside rules we never consciously agreed to.


I remember encountering the Kobayashi Maru as a kid and feeling almost immediately fascinated by Kirk’s response to it.


For anyone whose childhood somehow escaped Star Trek, the Kobayashi Maru is a Starfleet training simulation built around an unwinnable scenario. Every available decision eventually leads to failure.


Kirk rejected the premise.


He reprogrammed the simulation.


Technically, he cheated, which naturally made me love the whole thing even more.


What stayed with me had very little to do with science fiction. Kirk recognized that everyone else was trying to solve the problem inside the conditions they had been given, while he was willing to question whether those conditions deserved to remain intact in the first place.


That idea lodged itself somewhere in my brain.


Sometimes a problem feels impossible because we have become incredibly committed to the frame in which the problem was presented.


Change the frame and the impossible problem occasionally becomes a much more interesting question.


I suppose I have spent much of my life doing some version of that, first unconsciously and eventually for a living.


At my core, I am probably some strange collision of storyteller, strategist, process-improvement engineer, amateur psychologist, and guy who will absolutely move the furniture if the room feels wrong. I tend to walk into businesses, conversations, relationships, or ideas and become curious about the friction almost immediately.


I want to understand what everyone is trying to accomplish, where the resistance lives, which assumptions have quietly hardened into fact, and whether the accepted route still makes sense now that nobody can remember who drew the original map.


Eventually I usually arrive at some version of the same question.


What are we assuming has to be true?


That question has become one of the most useful tools I own because human beings are remarkably talented at inheriting architecture and then forgetting that anybody built it.


We do this with businesses all the time. We adopt somebody else’s definition of growth, build teams because successful companies apparently have teams, narrow our work because an internet stranger told us riches were hiding in the niches, and keep polishing an offer we stopped caring about two years ago because the market already knows us for it and changing direction feels vaguely irresponsible.


We do the same thing with life.


We inherit definitions of success from people whose lives we would never actually choose, carry ideas about money that were formed in households where money meant something entirely different, and keep performing versions of ourselves that once earned love, safety, approval, or belonging long after the circumstances that created those performances have disappeared.


Eventually the inheritance becomes architecture.


We begin living inside rules we cannot remember choosing.


That realization has softened my relationship with rebellion because age, among its many indignities, occasionally introduces humility.


For years I assumed questioning the map made me smarter than the people following it. Then life provided enough examples of me confidently wandering through the woods without water to complicate that theory.


Some structures contain accumulated wisdom. The reason I can board an airplane without personally inspecting the engine is that thousands of people have agreed to follow rules I do not understand. Contracts work because we collectively decided words should mean something after everybody signs them, and food safety is considerably more pleasant than discovering through experimentation which temperature chicken becomes dangerous… which incidentally happened to me last night in Gaffney SC… another story perhaps.


Structure creates enormous freedom when the thing underneath it still matters.


The harder question is what happens when the structure outlives the reason it was created. That is where discernment becomes much more useful than rebellion.


These days, when I encounter a rule that irritates me, I try to understand what it was originally designed to protect. Sometimes there is wisdom sitting underneath it and I am simply the asshole who arrived twenty minutes ago and believes he has invented efficiency. Other times the world has changed, the original problem has disappeared, and everyone is still following the procedure because nobody wants to be the first person in the meeting to raise a hand and ask why this thing exists.


That dynamic is everywhere in life and business.


A founder tells me the messaging feels muddy, so naturally everyone begins rewriting the homepage. Revenue slows down, so somebody proposes a new marketing campaign. The company feels complicated, so another system gets added to organize the systems already organizing the complexity.


Eventually six intelligent adults are standing around improving the furniture while the foundation underneath them is making noises nobody particularly wants to discuss… that is usually when I start pulling on the thread.


Maybe the founder believes growth requires a larger company because size became synonymous with success somewhere along the way. Maybe they keep forcing themselves into a niche that made perfect sense five years ago and now feels like wearing the suit I wore last week that I can no longer breathe in. Maybe an entire offer exists because customers once wanted it, even though both the company and the person running it have moved somewhere else.


The visible problem may be very real, but the more interesting question is often sitting underneath it, asking who decided the conditions had to remain exactly as they are.


This is probably the throughline connecting far more of my work than I realized for a long time.


People usually arrive with the problem they can see because that is how human beings work. We describe the thing making noise, but we rarely begin with the invisible belief quietly powering the machinery behind it.


So we start there and work backward… reverse engineer, excavate, extract, rebuild


Sometimes the existing structure simply needs to work better. Sometimes the original rule contains something worth preserving. And every once in a while, we realize everyone has been trying to win a game whose conditions stopped making sense years ago.


Those are my favorite conversations.


The parking signs are the easy rules to notice, the difficult ones however, rarely come with signs.


They arrive much earlier and usually sound perfectly reasonable. Be responsible. Choose the sensible path. Make everyone proud. Keep the peace. Build something respectable. Become successful enough that you can finally stop worrying about whether you are successful. Stay recognizable enough that the people around you never have to renegotiate their understanding of who you are.


Nobody necessarily sits us down and hands us these instructions, which may be precisely why they become so effective, they simply seep into the walls.


Family gives us some. Culture adds others. School, business, relationships, ambition, fear, and the peculiar little survival strategies we invent along the way contribute their own clauses until one day we discover we have become extraordinarily competent at succeeding inside a simulation we never consciously chose.


That, to me, is where the Kobayashi Maru becomes more interesting than a clever Star Trek story.


Eventually life presents us with situations where every available choice seems wrong because we are still treating the existing conditions as sacred.


Stay in the career and remain miserable, or leave and become irresponsible. Keep growing the business and lose yourself inside it, or slow down and feel like you failed. Remain recognizable to everyone around you, or change enough that some people stop understanding you.


Those choices can feel brutally real while we are standing inside them.


Then somebody asks a different question.


What if these are not the only choices?


That question has changed more things in my life than I can count.


It has also caused a few parking violations, so enlightenment clearly remains an unfinished project.


What I am becoming more interested in now is conscious authorship, because rebellion for its own sake eventually becomes another kind of prison. Spending your life defining yourself against the rules still allows the rules to define you.


There is something far more powerful about understanding the system clearly enough to decide which parts deserve your respect, which parts deserve renovation, and which parts can be thanked for their service and quietly escorted from the building.


That is where agency lives, and maybe that is the question worth carrying around this week.


Which rule are you still following simply because you inherited them, and what might become possible if you understood why it was there before deciding whether it still deserves a place in your life?


A surprising amount of my work begins somewhere inside that question. Someone brings me a business problem, a decision, an idea, or a knot they have been wrestling with for months, and eventually we discover an assumption underneath it that nobody had thought to examine because it had been sitting there for so long it started looking like reality.


If you are carrying one of those, bring me the knot, we’ll find the thread.


About Deevo


Deevo Tindall is the founder of The Brand Storyteller, although depending on the day he is equally comfortable being described as a strategist, storyteller, photographer, advisor, professional question-asker, and occasional pain in the ass.


He works with founders, leaders, and other capable humans who have become close enough to their own businesses, stories, or decisions that everything has started looking slightly blurry. His work usually begins by finding the assumption hiding underneath the obvious problem and ends somewhere around clearer language, better decisions, and considerably less expensive wandering.


When he is away from work, he can usually be found with a camera, near an ocean, arguing with an unnecessary rule, or attempting to understand why intelligent people continue making beautifully complicated versions of relatively simple mistakes.


With Gratitude, Deevo 704 728 2658 www.thebrandstoryteller.com

Comments


bottom of page